How to Choose a Tie: Width, Fabric, Pattern and Colour

Robb Pollard

How to Choose a Tie: Width, Fabric, Pattern and Colour

A tie is the smallest garment a man owns and the one that does the most talking. Knots are a separate subject. This is about choosing the tie itself.

The knots are in how to tie a tie and the collar each belongs in is in how to choose a shirt collar and cuff. This assumes you can tie one and want to know which to buy.

Man in a navy bespoke suit and red tie in a formal garden

Width, and why the lapel decides it

The widest part of the tie should sit close to the widest part of your lapel. Much narrower and the chest looks empty; much wider and the jacket looks borrowed. Most ties and most lapels fall in the same band, roughly two and three quarter to three and a half inches. The mismatches are a narrow tie against a generous peak lapel, and a broad tie against a slim notch.

Build counts too: a broad man in a narrow tie looks as though he ran out of cloth. The shapes are in notch, peak or shawl.

Length, and where the tip should sit

A tied tie finishes at the middle of the waistband, the tip just covering the belt line. About fifty-eight inches suits most men of ordinary height tying a four-in-hand. A larger knot eats two or three inches, so a tall man, or anyone who ties a full Windsor, needs more cloth. If every tie you own finishes short, ask for a longer blade.

The silks and weaves, and what each one does

Cloth decides more than pattern does. Pattern is what people notice; cloth is what you live with.

  • Grenadine. A fine gauze silk with a tiny open weave, matte rather than glossy, tying a small firm knot with a willing dimple. One serious tie should be a navy grenadine.
  • Repp. Fine diagonal ribs, the cloth of the striped regimental ties. The rib gives a crisp knot and the diagonal lifts a plain suit.
  • Shantung. Slubbed and irregular, dry rather than shiny, which makes a plain colour look considered. Good in warm weather.
  • Printed silk. A smooth foulard or twill, printed rather than woven. Right for a small pattern, and it gives a small knot, so a spread collar wants a larger one.
  • Knitted silk. Square ended and soft, the least formal silk tie. It belongs with an odd jacket or a flannel suit.
  • Wool and cashmere. Winter cloth. It takes tweed and flannel properly and looks stranded against a sharp worsted. Thick, so tie a four-in-hand.
  • Linen. Summer cloth, dry and crumpled by design. It wrinkles, and the wrinkling is the point.

The principle is texture answering texture. A smooth worsted takes a smooth silk; flannel, tweed or an open summer weave takes surface. How those cloths wear is in suit fabric types.

Pattern, and the rule about scale

The usual advice is never to mix patterns, and it is poor advice. Patterns of clearly different scale sit together happily; patterns of similar scale fight. It is a question of size, not type.

Against a plain suit and shirt almost any tie works. A widely spaced suit stripe takes a small foulard; a chalk stripe takes a bolder stripe the other way. Against a check, go smaller and quieter, or plain with texture. With three patterns, let one dominate. The suit patterns are in suit patterns, stripes, checks and weaves.

Colour against navy, grey and charcoal

Navy is the most hospitable suit colour there is. It takes burgundy, bottle green, silver grey and any blue clearly darker or lighter than itself, though not a blue close to its own. Mid grey carries stronger colour, nothing in the suit competing. Charcoal is least forgiving: keep to colours darker than the suit.

Choose the tie against the shirt too, since the knot touches the collar and nothing else. A pale blue shirt warms a burgundy tie; a white shirt sharpens it.

A black necktie is not black tie

Confusing these is the commonest mistake we are asked about. Black tie means a dinner jacket and a black bow tie, which our page for custom tuxedos and black tie sets out, with the method in how to tie a bow tie. A black four-in-hand necktie is right at a funeral with a dark suit, and in knitted silk or wool with an odd jacket. It is wrong under a dinner jacket, at a wedding, and usually in an office. See what to wear to a funeral.

Lining and construction, and why a good tie hangs straight

Turn a tie over. A well made one is cut from three pieces of silk on the true bias, joined by two diagonal seams, and folded by hand around a wool interlining with one loose slip stitch.

Cloth cut on the bias wants to twist, and a loose stitch lets the tie move and spring back rather than set into a spiral. A tie that corkscrews was cut off the bias, or stitched too tightly. The interlining decides the knot: a heavier wool lining fills out a small one, a lighter one keeps a thick silk from becoming a fist. Let the tie hang. It should fall dead straight.

Care and storage

Untie a tie every time, reversing the knot rather than dragging the narrow end through it, which bruises the cloth beneath. Then hang it, or roll it loosely in a drawer, and give it a day before wearing it again. Never iron silk directly and never dry clean a tie, since solvent flattens the hand of the silk. Blot a spill with a dry cloth, and retire a tie gone shiny at the knot. More in how to care for a bespoke suit.

The one thing you can change daily

Mr James makes suits and shirts, each cut from a pattern belonging to one person. A suit is a long decision, a shirt a medium one. A tie is the short one, and the only thing a man can change daily without changing the suit.

The collar we cut for you is set for the knot you tie, as our page for custom shirts in Los Angeles sets out. Every garment here is full canvas and fully bespoke, made by hand in the house's own atelier in Southern Brittany, France. We do not offer made to measure. Allow 4 to 12 weeks for a suit, two to four weeks for shirts, priced at consultation.

Questions we are often asked

How wide should a tie be?

As wide as your lapel at its widest point. Most sit between two and three quarter and three and a half inches, so measure the suit you wear most.

What is the best tie to own first?

A navy grenadine. Matte and open, it ties a small firm knot and sits correctly on a navy, grey or charcoal suit with any shirt you own.

Can you wear a patterned tie with a striped suit?

Yes, provided the patterns are of clearly different scale. A widely spaced suit stripe takes a small foulard; a chalk stripe takes a bolder stripe the other way. Two stripes of similar width will fight.

Is a black necktie the same as black tie?

No. Black tie means a dinner jacket with a black bow tie. A black four-in-hand necktie is not evening wear. It belongs at a funeral, or in knitted silk with an odd jacket.

Why does my tie twist?

Because it was not cut on the bias, or the slip stitch down the back was pulled too tight. A properly made tie is cut on the true bias and held by one loose stitch that lets it move and return.

How should a tie be stored?

Hung, or rolled loosely in a drawer. Untie by reversing the knot rather than pulling the narrow end through, and leave the tie a day so the silk recovers.

Come and be measured

The first consultation takes an hour, costs nothing, and includes around thirty measurements and three photographs. Fittings are unlimited. We are at 221 Culver Blvd, Playa del Rey, CA 90293, open seven days a week, 10 AM to 6 PM, by appointment, with free parking, and you will meet Robb. Take a time on our fitting calendar, start from book a fitting, or telephone 310-503-3592.

Back to blog