Custom Dress Shirts: What to Order First, and What Comes Next
Robb Pollard
Custom dress shirts at Mr James are priced at consultation, cut to a pattern drawn for one person and made by hand in the house's own atelier in Southern Brittany, France. Two to four weeks. The choices available are set out on our custom shirts page. What follows is the question men actually ask once they have decided to have shirts made: in what order, and how many.
A man will spend a month choosing cloth for a suit he wears twice a month, and ten minutes buying the shirt he wears five days a week. A suit feels like an occasion and a shirt feels like a consumable. But the shirt sits four inches from your face, and it is the only garment left when the jacket comes off at six o'clock.
Start with three, not one and not twelve
Most men arrive intending to order one shirt, and a few intending to order a dozen. One is too few to learn from. A dozen commits you to decisions you have not tested, and twelve shirts with a collar a quarter of an inch too tall is a quarter of an inch you live with for years.
Three gives a week's wear with a rotation, enough to find out how the collar behaves by four in the afternoon, whether the cuff stays put when you reach across a table, and whether the body has the room you want when you sit in a car. Wear them for a month, then tell us what to change. The pattern is adjusted before the next set is cut, which is the whole advantage of owning your pattern. What you are looking for in each of those checks is set out in how a dress shirt should fit.
White, then blue, then the one you actually want
The first shirt should be white, in a fine poplin. It goes under every suit you own, and it is the one you reach for when you have not thought about it. Plain white is also the hardest shirt to get away with when it does not fit, which makes it an honest test of a new pattern.
The second should be pale blue. Blue is kinder than white against most complexions and photographs more softly. Between the two you can dress for almost any day of your life.
The third is yours: a check, a stripe, an end-on-end that reads as a solid across the room and as texture up close, an oxford for the weekend.
Settle the collar once, then leave it alone
The collar is most of the shirt, and the usual mistake is to treat every order as a fresh decision. A wardrobe in which each shirt has a slightly different collar is one in which nothing quite matches.
Pick a height that suits your neck and a spread that balances your face and agrees with the knot you honestly tie, then keep it. One shape, repeated, is what makes a set of shirts look considered. Put the variety in the cloth instead. Which shape that should be is set out in how to choose a shirt collar and cuff.
Cuffs that suit the week you actually have
A single cuff with one or two buttons is the everyday shirt, and it should be the first three unless your week calls for otherwise. A double cuff wants links, and links want a jacket. If you wear a suit daily, one of the three can be a double cuff.
What matters more than the style is the pair of measurements behind it. The cuff has to be close enough that the shirt does not travel down the back of your hand when you extend your arm, and open enough to pass over the wrist without a struggle. Ready-made shirts rarely manage both, because the two are related and only one is ever taken. The half inch of cuff showing past a jacket sleeve is a matter of shirt and jacket agreeing, which is covered in our notes on how a suit should fit. Single and double cuffs, and the collar shapes they sit under, are compared in shirt collars and cuffs explained.
Cloth, and the case for owning more than you need
Poplin is smooth, fine and slightly cool, and the crispest thing under a jacket. Twill has a diagonal weave and a faint sheen, drapes more softly and creases less, which counts for something in a car in this city. Oxford is heavier and more textured, belongs with odd jackets and no tie, and improves for years. Higher yarn counts feel finer and are also more delicate, so for a shirt worn weekly we would point you at something sturdier. The buttons are thick mother-of-pearl buttons as standard, cut from shell rather than pressed from resin, which is why thickness is the thing to ask about on any shirt.
The case for owning more shirts than you need is that cotton wears by friction and by laundering rather than by time. A shirt worn once a fortnight lasts several times as long as one worn twice a week, which makes a larger rotation cheaper by the year.
The formal shirt can wait
A dress shirt for black tie is a marcella or fine pleated front, a turndown collar, studs rather than a placket, and a double cuff. There is no hurry about it. Order it when there is a date in the diary, and alongside the dinner suit rather than separately, so the collar and the lapel are decided together. There is more on the rest of that outfit on our tuxedo page.
Questions we are often asked
How many dress shirts should a man own?
Seven to ten if you wear one five days a week, and five if you wear one twice a week. The number matters less than the rotation. A shirt that rests a fortnight between wearings lasts several times longer than one worn twice a week, so a larger wardrobe costs less by the year than a small one.
Which colour should the first custom shirt be?
White, in a fine poplin. It goes under everything, and it shows a fit fault more plainly than any other colour, which makes it the honest first test of a new pattern. Pale blue second.
Should all my shirts have the same collar?
Broadly yes. One collar height and spread, chosen to suit your neck and your face and the knot you actually tie, repeated across the wardrobe, is what makes a set of shirts look deliberate. A soft button-down worn without a tie is a reasonable exception.
Is it better to order shirts one at a time or in a set?
Three to begin with, then sets of three or four once the pattern has settled. One is too few to learn anything from over a month of wear, and a dozen commits you to a collar you have not yet lived in.
How long should a custom dress shirt last?
Several years in a reasonable rotation, and longer if you wash cool, hang it straight away and keep it out of the dryer. Collar points and cuff edges go first, and both can be remade before the body of the shirt is finished.
Can you copy the collar from a shirt I already like?
We can measure a collar you like and use it as a starting point, and it is worth bringing the shirt in. It is a starting point rather than an answer, because a collar that suited the shirt it came from may not suit the way your neck sits once your own pattern is drawn.
Come and be measured
The first consultation lasts an hour and there is no charge for it. You meet Robb, and we take around thirty measurements and three photographs so that posture is recorded rather than guessed at, then go through cloth with the prices in front of you.
We are appointment only, seven days a week, with forty-eight hours' notice. The showroom is at 221 Culver Blvd, Playa del Rey, CA 90293, with free parking front and back. Book a private consultation, or telephone 310-503-3592 and we will find a time. You can also write to mrjames@bespokemrjames.com.